Staff Directory

Welcome to Our Staff Directory

John Mahaffey​
Agency Owner

Phone: (469) 707-3063
Email: [email protected]

​John Mahaffey, the Agency Principal of Mahaffey Insurance Agency, boasts over 20 years of experience in the commercial insurance industry. His extensive knowledge and dedication have helped numerous businesses secure the right coverage to protect their assets and ensure long-term success. John's commitment to excellence and personalized service sets him apart in the field.

When he's not working, John cherishes spending quality time with his family, enjoying rounds of golf, and fishing in the beautiful Texas outdoors. His passion for both his profession and his hobbies reflects his well-rounded and dedicated approach to life and work.

Anna Taylor​
Chief Administrative Officer

Phone: (469) 707-3063
Email: [email protected]

​​Anna Taylor is a skilled insurance professional with over 25 years of experience in the industry, spanning various roles across different agencies in the metroplex. Following in the footsteps of her late Aunt, Anna is a second-generation insurance specialist who has demonstrated a profound commitment to her craft.

Having started her journey as an Account Manager specializing in Commercial Lines, Anna has since transitioned to the role of Chief Administrative Officer at Mahaffey Insurance Agency.

Anna's longstanding relationship with John, dating back to their time at a prior agency, underscores her strong network and collaborative spirit. Since the inception of Mahaffey Insurance Agency, she has played an instrumental role in its establishment and growth.

Anna and her husband have 5 children and 2 English bulldogs. She loves her family, country music and racing.

Mike Foster
Producer

Phone: (469) 707-3063
Email: [email protected]

​Mike Foster is a newly licensed commercial insurance agent at Mahaffey Insurance Agency, bringing a fresh perspective from his 20 years of experience in the mortgage industry. His deep understanding of financial services and client needs equips him with the skills to provide exceptional insurance solutions. In his free time, Mike enjoys golfing and spending quality time with his family, reflecting his balanced approach to life and work.

Tonya Sims
Senior Account Manager

Phone: (469) 707-3063
Email: [email protected]

​With over 20 years of experience in commercial insurance, Tonya Sims excels as Senior Account Manager. Her expertise in risk management, policy analysis, and client relations ensures tailored insurance solutions for businesses. Known for her attention to detail and proactive approach, Tonya consistently delivers optimal outcomes. Outside of work, she enjoys staying active by spending time with her family, dogs, friends, crafting and community service work.

Ana Garcia
Customer Service Representative

Phone: (469) 707-3063
Email: [email protected]

​Ana Garcia's extensive experience in insurance, spanning over a quarter-century, reflects her deep commitment to her profession. With over ten years dedicated to her previous agency, Ana has honed her skills in providing meticulous customer service. Holding a license as a General Lines Agent and currently serving as a Customer Service Representative, Ana brings a wealth of expertise to her role, offering personalized solutions and unparalleled assistance to her clients. ​

Her Texan roots are evident in her values of integrity and teamwork, which she embodies wholeheartedly. Ana's dedication to her craft and her community exemplifies the true spirit of service, making her a trusted ally for those seeking insurance guidance and support.

​New Braunfels Branch

John Waymer
Producer

Phone: (469) 707-3063
Email: [email protected]

​John is a veteran commercial insurance agent with over 40 years of experience in the industry. Throughout his distinguished career, John has built a reputation for his deep expertise, unwavering dedication, and personalized service. Specializing in used car dealerships and tailoring comprehensive insurance solutions for dealerships of all sizes, he has helped countless clients protect their assets, mitigate risks, and achieve peace of mind. ​

John's journey in the insurance industry began in 1982 and over the decades, he has witnessed and adapted to the evolving landscape of commercial insurance. His extensive knowledge spans various sectors, including used car dealerships, auto repair, paint and body shops and auto recyclers. This breadth of experience allows him to understand the unique challenges and needs of these industries, providing clients with the most relevant and effective coverage options. ​

Known for his client-centric approach, John takes the time to thoroughly assess each client's specific requirements, ensuring that every policy is customized to offer optimal protection. His commitment to building long-term relationships has earned him a loyal client base, many of whom have relied on his expertise for decades. He is a true leader in the industry and an incredible asset to our agency.

Susan Adams
Producer

Phone: (469) 707-3063
Email: [email protected]

Angelique Day​
Account Manager

Phone: (469) 707-3063
Email: [email protected]

​Angelique Day is an experienced commercial insurance agent with over 20 years in the industry. She specializes in crafting tailored insurance solutions for businesses of all sizes, ensuring comprehensive coverage and risk management. Angelique’s expertise spans property, liability, and workers' compensation insurance, backed by her deep understanding of industry trends and regulations. Her commitment to client success and proactive approach makes her a trusted advisor. Angelique is dedicated to helping businesses thrive by protecting their assets and minimizing risks.

Celeste Heller​
Account Manager

Phone: (469) 707-3063
Email: [email protected]

​​Celeste Heller is a newly licensed insurance agent dedicated to providing personalized and comprehensive coverage solutions for your business. With a strong background in business ownership, customer service and a passion for helping clients minimize risks; Celeste offers tailored advice to meet individual needs. Her commitment to excellence and continuous learning ensures clients receive top-notch service and reliable protection.

Royse City Office:
106 E Main St.
Suite 101
Royse City, TX  75189
​(469) 707-3063​

New Braunfels Office:
445 N Seguin Ave
New Braunfels, TX 78130
(800) 447-5152
Click Here to Email Us

Navigation

Homepage
Insurance Quotes
Contact Us
Agent Login

Connect With Us

Share This Page

Contact Us

Mahaffey Insurance Agency LLC
Royse City Office:
106 E Main St.
Suite 101
Royse City, TX  75189
​(469) 707-3063​
New Braunfels Office:
445 N Seguin Ave
​New Braunfels, TX 78130
(800) 447-5152
​Click Here to Email Us
Website by InsuranceSplash